Showing posts with label Evergreen Specific Plan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Evergreen Specific Plan. Show all posts

Monday, June 7, 2010

Letter to San Jose Envision 2040 Task Force on backloading North Coyote and East Evergreen

(The letter below was submitted to the San Jose General Plan Task Force, discussing why and how the City should "backload" development in the greenspace areas of North Coyote and east Evergreen until until other areas have been fully developed, if at all.  -Brian)


Envision San Jose 2040 Task Force

Re:  following the City Council's direction, some options on "backloading" development in North Coyote Valley and east Evergreen

Dear Task Force Members;

On April 20th, the City Council directed that the General Plan revision process include consideration of "backloading" greenfield development in North Coyote Valley and east Evergreen until jobs capacity has been fully developed in other areas of the City.  The vote was to entertain and consider the idea, not necessarily to do it.  To provide feedback from the Task Force to the City Council and staff, we suggest the Task Force hold two votes.  First the Task Force should consider whether it supports the general principle of backloading, which is modifies the idea that jobs development should occur anytime and anywhere to an idea that prioritizes redevelopment over conversion of open space.  Second, the Task Force should vote on different options on backloading to recommend to the City Council, a recommendation that could be useful regardless of the outcome of the first vote, because the City Council must make the final decision on General Plan issues.

We strongly urge the Task Force to support backloading, and to recommend a policy that only exempts existing permits and entitlements.

1.  Supporting the principle of backloading.  We will not repeat the argument made at length to the Task Force and to the City Council that converting valuable farmlands, ranchland, and open space buffers to development when the rest of the City needs redevelopment is a mistake.  San Jose has a chance to grow upward instead of outward, and places like downtown, North First Street, and Evergreen would benefit if development is not siphoned off elsewhere.  The idea would not permanently forbid development of North Coyote and east Evergreen, although the Council is aware that the effect may be to stop development. While existing permits such as the Coyote Valley Research Park would not be affected, renewal of unutilized permits would be.  Please see the attached April 26th letter for more information. 

We suggest a simple motion on this issue that provides feedback to staff and City Council on the general idea that they can use regardless of how the City proceeds on the second question.

2. Options for backloading.

Our recommendation and proposed General Plan Policy:

Preferred Policy:  "New permits for industrial or commercial development of undeveloped lands in North Coyote Valley and east Evergreen shall not be issued until the planned jobs capacity has been reached in all other parts of the City."

Please note the above policy contains an implicit exemption, in that any truly exceptional proposal could be approved by the City Council through a General Plan amendment, something that a "truly exceptional" proposal shouldn't have trouble achieving.

Alternative policies:

Alternative 1: "New permits for industrial or commercial development of undeveloped lands in North Coyote Valley and east Evergreen shall not be issued until the planned jobs capacity has been reached in all other parts of the City; provided however that exceptions for projects of unique economic opportunity creating at least X thousand jobs shall be allowed when the "trigger" conditions for City fiscal health and governmental services, described for development in mid-Coyote Valley in the San Jose 2020 General Plan, are also met."

We suggest the project be a minimum of 10,000 jobs to ensure a size of project that could not be easily accommodated elsewhere.  We recommend this alternative if an exception is to be included.


Alternative 2: "New permits for industrial or commercial development of undeveloped lands in North Coyote Valley and east Evergreen shall not be issued until the planned jobs capacity has been reached in all other parts of the City; provided however that exceptions for projects of unique economic opportunity creating at least X thousand jobs shall be allowed."

Removes the trigger concept.


Alternative 3: "New permits for industrial or commercial development of undeveloped lands in North Coyote Valley and east Evergreen shall not be issued until the planned jobs capacity has been reached in all other parts of the City; provided however that exceptions for large projects of unique economic opportunity shall be allowed."

Instead of providing a set number, it merely says the project must be "large."

Please contact us with any questions.

Sincerely,
Brian A. Schmidt
Legislative Advocate, Santa Clara County

Friday, May 7, 2010

Letter to Envision San Jose 2040 Task Force on "backloading" greenfield development

(We made some important progress with San Jose City Council, and this letter followed up on that issue.  -Brian)


April 26, 2010

Envision San Jose Task Force

Re:  Last week's decision by the City Council to consider "backloading" greenfield development

Dear Task Force Members;

Committee for Green Foothills would like to thank the San Jose City Council for accepting our suggestion that the General Plan revision process include consideration of "backloading" greenfield development in North Coyote Valley and east Evergreen until jobs capacity has been fully developed in other areas of the City.  The vote was to entertain and consider the idea, not necessarily to do it, but we are satisfied with and appreciate the decision.  I will also note that the idea has been briefly discussed before – I specifically raised it at the last Task Force meeting – but further consideration is always helpful.

A written version of my suggestion at last week's City Council meeting is attached below (I may have diverged slightly from the text when speaking).  As you will see from the text, I disclosed to City Councilmembers who may have been unaware of it that the proposal might mean the greenfield areas will not be developed before 2040, and they still supported consideration of the idea.

Regarding Coyote Valley Research Park, the only entitled project I am aware of in North Coyote or east Evergreen, the permits would allow them to develop if they still wish to, and upon development would no longer be considered greenfields.  If, however, the permit holders continue with their decade-long failure to build, then the backloading proposal as expressed to the City Council would mean they could not receive new permits until jobs capacity had been reached elsewhere.  Of course, in both this case and the hypothetical example given by Mayor Reed of a proposed development in east Evergreen, any proposal with sufficient advantages for the City could be accommodated with a General Plan amendment.

We are sure that the City Council direction intended this backloading proposal receive sufficient consideration, and we trust City staff to ensure that is the case.

Please contact us with any questions.

Sincerely,

Sincerely,

Brian A. Schmidt
Legislative Advocate, Santa Clara County



(Written version of the oral comments given by Brian Schmidt, Committee for Green Foothills, to the City Council meeting on April 20, 2010.  Actual oral comments may have diverged slightly from the written version.  The comment proposal was suggested for consideration in the General Plan revision process in a friendly amendment by Councilmember Ash Kalra, accepted by Councilmember Sam Liccardo and approved by the City Council.)


We support a minor but important variation on the current land use proposal that jobs development should happen anytime, anywhere in City limits.

We would like to ask the City Council to recommend a proposal to "backload" development of open spaces and greenfield until after other areas are developed.

 San Jose greenfields are East Evergreen and parts of North Coyote Valley, and the idea is that these areas would not develop until after jobs capacity has been fully developed elsewhere in the City, where greenfields aren't at risk.  This proposal would not affect existing permits like the Coyote Valley Research Park, the already-developed western half of the Evergreen, or the Water Treatment Plant area that is undergoing separate planning.

The advantage of this suggestion is it would encourage development where it is needed – Evergreen Village and East Evergreen, Edenvale, downtown, and North First Street.  It is possible that the suggestion means these Greenfield areas are not developed before 2040, but so long as the same development happens elsewhere that needs redevelopment, then that result is a good feature and not a bug in the General Plan.  Other areas of the City have the capacity for the same kind of development elsewhere, and if by some strange chance an important proposal could only happen on greenfields, such a proposal could be tied to a General Plan amendment.

Again we request that you ask staff to include this suggestion in some form as the revision process moves forward.  I'd be happy to answer any questions.

Wednesday, May 16, 2007

San Jose makes the right decision on the Evergreen project

Following up on our Action Alert, I'm glad to report that San Jose has decided to defer action on Evergreen development until it has revised the City's General Plan. See the Mercury News:

The San Jose City Council rejected a proposal Tuesday night to build homes on land set aside for future industrial growth in the city's Evergreen district and voted to require industrial development before housing in the surrounding area.

The proposal involves the loss of open space and especially of burrowing owl habitat and would have set a bad precedent for Coyote Valley. We're glad the City Council voted the way they did.

-Brian

Friday, May 11, 2007

CGF Action Alert: Protect Open Space and Stop Bad Planning in San Jose's Evergreen District!

(This may also be published on our Action Alert page, but in the interest of time, I'm putting it here on the blog as well. -Brian)
------------
At their meeting on Tuesday, May 15, the San Jose City Council will decide whether to approve an updated Specific Plan for the Evergreen District that relies on an outdated City General Plan, has numerous environmental impacts, and could harm efforts to slow the developers’ land rush in Coyote Valley.

Please join us in asking the City Council to defer a major update of the Evergreen Specific Plan until after the City General Plan has been revised.

What's Happening:

Developers in east San Jose are proposing conversion of 500 acres of land to housing that is now mostly designated for industrial and commercial purposes. Currently, housing makes more money for developers, but less money for the City’s coffers. The City is considering going along with this proposal, despite the fact that San Jose uses the lack of space for commercial and industrial uses in the city as an excuse to sprawl into Coyote Valley, destroying farmland forever.

Although on a smaller scale than Coyote Valley, the Evergreen proposal will have similar impacts on traffic and air quality. Of particular concern is the 50-acres of prime farmland and a smaller amount of burrowing owl habitat that will be lost. Developers have opposed doing environmental mitigation to compensate for the lost farmland and owl habitat. They did not want to meet the standard that the City proposes for Coyote Valley, a standard that is itself insufficient.

San Jose has not revised its General Plan since 1994, and is now starting a revision that will take two to three years to complete. As is the case with Coyote Valley, an immediate, drastic change to the Evergreen Specific Plan that relies on an outdated General Plan is putting the cart before the horse. It would be far better for the City to revise the General Plan and then analyze the proposals it has received for Evergreen to decide its policy there.

Committee for Green Foothills strongly supports deferral of this project.

Why this is important:

It is likely that some change in zoning and the Specific Plan for Evergreen will be needed, but such changes should be done under the right circumstances and not at the expense of the environment. Making these changes under an updated General Plan that corresponds to the San Jose of today makes better decision-making far more likely. Constant maneuvering and pressure by developers also give a reason to put a brake on this project.

Handling Evergreen development correctly increases the chance of doing the same with the even-bigger Coyote Valley decision, so the decision on Tuesday is important.

For more information on these proposals, read the Mercury News editorial, and the Draft EIR summary.

What You Can Do:

Please ask the City Council to defer a decision on the Evergreen Specific Plan until the General Plan has been revised, and to ensure that loss of farmland and burrowing owl habitat be mitigated, if and when a decision on Evergreen ever happens.

Contact:
San Jose City Council:

Email the Mayor,

Email the City Council,

or fax (408) 277-3868

As always, please send a copy to us so we can track the efficiency of our work:
Fax (650) 968-8431 or action@GreenFoothills.org.

Thank you for speaking up for environmental protection!